Key Background
The parties had been involved in earlier UK trade mark litigation. In 2014, Thomas Pink successfully argued that Victoria’s Secret’s use of PINK in Europe infringed Thomas Pink’s registered trade marks. The resulting appeal was settled through a worldwide coexistence agreement signed in 2015.
The agreement was intended to resolve ongoing disputes and establish rules governing future use of marks containing the word PINK.
A significant point of context was that:
Victoria’s Secret had an established and substantial PINK business in the United States before the settlement agreement.
There was no evidence that Thomas Pink was using PINK as a standalone clothing brand in the US at the time the agreement was signed.
The Central Issue
The dispute focused on clause 5.5.2 of the settlement agreement.
In broad terms, Victoria’s Secret had agreed not to assert certain trade mark rights against Thomas Pink, subject to exceptions. The question was whether Thomas Pink's new US products fell within the protection of that non-assertion clause.
Thomas Pink argued that its products were sufficiently connected with the Thomas Pink business, meaning Victoria’s Secret was contractually prevented from suing.
Victoria’s Secret argued that the clause was concerned with branding and consumer perception, not merely corporate ownership or licensing arrangements. If the products were not perceived as being part of the THOMAS PINK brand, the contractual protection did not apply.
The Court’s Decision
The Court agreed with Victoria’s Secret.
The judge held that:
The settlement agreement was fundamentally a trade mark and branding agreement.
References to the"TP Business" meant a business conducted under the THOMAS PINK brand, not simply any business owned, controlled or licensed by Thomas Pink.
The clause should be interpreted from a trade mark perspective, asking whether consumers would associate the products with the THOMAS PINK brand.
It would make little commercial sense for Victoria’s Secret to have given Thomas Pink a broad right to use the PINK brand in the United States, where Victoria’s Secret already had a strong and valuable business under that mark.
The judge concluded that the settlement agreement did not prevent Victoria’s Secret from pursuing the Ohio infringement proceedings in relation to the products in question.
Thomas Pink’s Alternative Argument
Thomas Pink argued that even if Victoria’s Secret’s interpretation was correct, the products should still be protected because they carried THOMAS PINK labels inside the garments.
The Court rejected this argument.
The judge noted that, in the earlier UK litigation, it had already been recognised that consumers viewing a garment would focus on the prominent PINK branding displayed externally, rather than hidden internal labels. As a result, an internal THOMAS PINK label did not solve the problem.
Outcome
The Court held that the settlement agreement did not stop Victoria’s Secret from asserting its trade mark rights in the Ohio proceedings. Thomas Pink's request for an anti-suit injunction was refused.
The judge indicated that declaratory relief should be narrowly framed by reference to the products involved in the Ohio proceedings rather than creating broader rules for future disputes.
Key Takeaways
1. Branding matters more than ownership
The Court treated the agreement as being concerned with how consumers perceive brands, not simply who owns or licenses a business.
2. Trade mark coexistence agreements are interpreted commercially
The judge looked at the commercial realities existing when the agreement was signed. A construction that would have given Thomas Pink broad rights to use PINK in Victoria’s Secret’s core US market was considered commercially unlikely.
3. Hidden labels may not avoid trade mark issues
Where branding appears prominently on the outside of products, internal labels identifying a different brand may carry little weight.
4. Clear drafting is essential
The dispute arose from ambiguity in the wording of the non-assertion provisions. The case serves as a reminder that coexistence agreements should expressly define the scope of permitted uses, product ranges, territories and branding arrangements.
Practical Significance
This decision is a useful illustration of how courts approach trade mark coexistence and settlement agreements. Even where one party has agreed not to assert its trade mark rights, that protection may be interpreted narrowly if the surrounding agreement shows that the parties intended to preserve their respective core brands and markets.